Guides:Episode 21 OA vs. DC: Difference between revisions

From EvaWiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(add scene 10)
(8 intermediate revisions by 4 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
As with the rest of the DC episodes, a lot of the cuts were redrawn to be as similar as possible to the original ones and are almost indistinguishable from them, while others were radically modified. The "''On-Air Version''" of [[Episode 21]] present in the Renewal edition actually uses the '''DC''' version of those cuts that were redrawn with minimal changes, and simply omits the footage that wasn't present in the original OA. Exceptions to this rule will be noted below.
==[[FGC:Episode_21_Scene_01|Scene 01: Adam]]==
==[[FGC:Episode_21_Scene_01|Scene 01: Adam]]==


Line 85: Line 87:
| [[Image:21_C002B.jpg]]
| [[Image:21_C002B.jpg]]
|
|
|-
| [[FGC:Episode_21_Scene_02#cut_21_009|009]]
| [[Image:21_C009_oa.png]]
| [[Image:21_C009_dc.png]]
| In the OA edition, Misato removes her ID and handgun together from an interior jacket pocket. The result is a little awkward, as it looks like the two items are fused together. This is fixed in the DC edition, in which Misato's ID is already on the table in front of her, and she simply removes her handgun from her jacket pocket and places it on the table with her ID.
|-
|-
| [[FGC:Episode_21_Scene_02#cut_21_034|034]]
| [[FGC:Episode_21_Scene_02#cut_21_034|034]]
Line 98: Line 105:
|-
|-
|}
|}


==[[FGC:Episode_21_Scene_03|Scene 03: Rokubungi Gendo]]==
==[[FGC:Episode_21_Scene_03|Scene 03: Rokubungi Gendo]]==
Line 215: Line 219:
[[Image:21 C072b_oa.jpg]]
[[Image:21 C072b_oa.jpg]]
| [[Image:21_C072.jpg]]
| [[Image:21_C072.jpg]]
| The ship moves in the OA cut, while it remains stationary in the DC.
| The ship moves in the OA cut with respect to the "icebergs", while it remains stationary in the DC.
|-
|-
| [[FGC:Episode_21_Scene_04#cut_21_076|076]]
| [[FGC:Episode_21_Scene_04#cut_21_076|076]]
Line 254: Line 258:
[[Image:21 C327e.jpg]]
[[Image:21 C327e.jpg]]
| 104/105 OA were fused into 327 DC, while adding with new animation.
| 104/105 OA were fused into 327 DC, while adding with new animation.
''(On-Air Renewal follows the original OA)''
|-
|-
| [[FGC:Episode_21_Scene_04#cut_21_104-105|104]]
| [[FGC:Episode_21_Scene_04#cut_21_104-105|104]]
Line 279: Line 285:
! Comments
! Comments
|-
|-
| [[FGC:Episode_21_Scene_05#cut_05_111|111]]
| [[FGC:Episode_21_Scene_05#cut_21_111|111]]
| [[Image:21 C111a_oa.jpg]]
| [[Image:21 C111a_oa.jpg]]
[[Image:21 C111b_oa.jpg]]
[[Image:21 C111b_oa.jpg]]
Line 285: Line 291:
| The foreground moves in the OA.
| The foreground moves in the OA.
|-
|-
| [[FGC:Episode_21_Scene_05#cut_05_112|112]]
| [[FGC:Episode_21_Scene_05#cut_21_112|112]]
|
|
| [[Image:21 C112a.jpg]]
| [[Image:21 C112a.jpg]]
Line 293: Line 299:
| New cuts for the DC.
| New cuts for the DC.
|-
|-
| [[FGC:Episode_21_Scene_05#cut_05_113|113]]
| [[FGC:Episode_21_Scene_05#cut_21_113|113]]
|
|
| [[Image:21 C113a.jpg]]
| [[Image:21 C113a.jpg]]
Line 301: Line 307:
|
|
|-
|-
| [[FGC:Episode_21_Scene_05#cut_05_114|114]]
| [[FGC:Episode_21_Scene_05#cut_21_114|114]]
|
|
| [[Image:21 C114a.jpg]]
| [[Image:21 C114a.jpg]]
Line 309: Line 315:
|
|
|-
|-
| [[FGC:Episode_21_Scene_05#cut_05_115|115]]
| [[FGC:Episode_21_Scene_05#cut_21_115|115]]
|
|
| [[Image:21 C115a.jpg]]
| [[Image:21 C115a.jpg]]
Line 321: Line 327:
|
|
|-
|-
| [[FGC:Episode_21_Scene_05#cut_05_117|117]]
| [[FGC:Episode_21_Scene_05#cut_21_117|117]]
| [[Image:21 C117_oa.jpg]]
| [[Image:21 C117_oa.jpg]]
| [[Image:21 C117c.jpg]]
| [[Image:21 C117c.jpg]]
| The OA version of this cut has a text overlay (Gendo Ikari, Director)
| The OA version of this cut has a text overlay (Gendo Ikari, Director)
''(the On-Air Renewal version restores the caption)''
|-
|-
| [[FGC:Episode_21_Scene_05#cut_05_122|122]]
| [[FGC:Episode_21_Scene_05#cut_21_328|328]]
| [[Image:21 C122_oa.jpg]]
| [[Image:21 C122a.jpg]]
[[Image:21 C122b.jpg]]
| The DC zooms out slowly.
|-
| [[FGC:Episode_21_Scene_05#cut_05_328|328]]
|
|
| [[Image:21 C328a.jpg]]
| [[Image:21 C328a.jpg]]
Line 340: Line 343:
| New sequence for the DC. Fuyutsuki's dialogue about the similarity of the Geofront to the South Pole cavern was added for the DC.
| New sequence for the DC. Fuyutsuki's dialogue about the similarity of the Geofront to the South Pole cavern was added for the DC.
|-
|-
| [[FGC:Episode_21_Scene_05#cut_05_329|329]]
| [[FGC:Episode_21_Scene_05#cut_21_329|329]]
|
|
| [[Image:21 C329.jpg]]
| [[Image:21 C329.jpg]]
|
|
|-
|-
| [[FGC:Episode_21_Scene_05#cut_05_330|330]]
| [[FGC:Episode_21_Scene_05#cut_21_330|330]]
|
|
| [[Image:21 C330a.jpg]]
| [[Image:21 C330a.jpg]]
Line 351: Line 354:
|
|
|-
|-
| [[FGC:Episode_21_Scene_05#cut_05_331|331]]
| [[FGC:Episode_21_Scene_05#cut_21_331|331]]
|
|
| [[Image:21 C331a.jpg]]
| [[Image:21 C331a.jpg]]
Line 359: Line 362:
|
|
|-
|-
| [[FGC:Episode_21_Scene_05#cut_05_136|136]]
| [[FGC:Episode_21_Scene_05#cut_21_136|136]]
| [[Image:21 C136a_oa.jpg]]
| [[Image:21 C136a_oa.jpg]]
[[Image:21 C136b_oa.jpg]]
[[Image:21 C136b_oa.jpg]]
Line 370: Line 373:
| Redrawn for the DC.
| Redrawn for the DC.
|-
|-
| [[FGC:Episode_21_Scene_05#cut_05_137|137]]
| [[FGC:Episode_21_Scene_05#cut_21_137|137]]
| [[Image:21 C137a_oa.jpg]]
| [[Image:21 C137a_oa.jpg]]
[[Image:21 C137b_oa.jpg]]
[[Image:21 C137b_oa.jpg]]
Line 381: Line 384:
| Redrawn for the DC.
| Redrawn for the DC.
|-
|-
| [[FGC:Episode_21_Scene_05#cut_05_138|138]]
| [[FGC:Episode_21_Scene_05#cut_21_138|138]]
| [[Image:21 C138a_oa.jpg]]
| [[Image:21 C138a_oa.jpg]]
[[Image:21 C138b_oa.jpg]]
[[Image:21 C138b_oa.jpg]]
Line 388: Line 391:
| Redrawn for the DC. Ritsuko's jacket and hair look different.
| Redrawn for the DC. Ritsuko's jacket and hair look different.
|-
|-
| [[FGC:Episode_21_Scene_05#cut_05_140|140]]
| [[FGC:Episode_21_Scene_05#cut_21_140|140]]
| [[Image:21 C140_oa.jpg]]
| [[Image:21 C140_oa.jpg]]
| [[Image:21 C140.jpg]]
| [[Image:21 C140.jpg]]
| Redrawn for the DC.
| Redrawn for the DC.
|-
|-
| [[FGC:Episode_21_Scene_05#cut_05_142|142]]
| [[FGC:Episode_21_Scene_05#cut_21_142|142]]
| [[Image:21 C142_oa.jpg]]
| [[Image:21 C142_oa.jpg]]
| [[Image:21 C142.jpg]]
| [[Image:21 C142.jpg]]
| Redrawn for the DC.
| Redrawn for the DC.
|-
|-
| [[FGC:Episode_21_Scene_05#cut_05_143|143]]
| [[FGC:Episode_21_Scene_05#cut_21_143|143]]
| [[Image:21 C143_oa.jpg]]
| [[Image:21 C143_oa.jpg]]
| [[Image:21 C143.jpg]]
| [[Image:21 C143.jpg]]
| Redrawn for the DC.
| Redrawn for the DC.
|-
|-
| [[FGC:Episode_21_Scene_05#cut_05_144|144]]
| [[FGC:Episode_21_Scene_05#cut_21_144|144]]
| [[Image:21 C144a_oa.jpg]]
| [[Image:21 C144a_oa.jpg]]
[[Image:21 C144b_oa.jpg]]
[[Image:21 C144b_oa.jpg]]
Line 415: Line 418:
|-
|-
|}
|}


==[[FGC:Episode_21_Scene_06|Scene 06: A Mother]]==
==[[FGC:Episode_21_Scene_06|Scene 06: A Mother]]==
Line 428: Line 428:
|-
|-
| [[FGC:Episode_21_Scene_06#cut_21_Title2|Title2]]
| [[FGC:Episode_21_Scene_06#cut_21_Title2|Title2]]
|
| [[Image:21 eyecatch_oa.jpg]]
| [[Image:21 eyecatch.jpg]]
| [[Image:21 eyecatch_dc.jpg]]
|
| [[Image:21 eyecatch.jpg]] The ''21''' designation for the DC episode was added in Renewal.
|-
|-
| [[FGC:Episode_21_Scene_06#cut_21_147B|147B]]
| [[FGC:Episode_21_Scene_06#cut_21_147B|147B]]
Line 649: Line 649:
[[Image:21 C174b.jpg]]
[[Image:21 C174b.jpg]]
| Most of the images in the OA were recycled from [[FGC:Episode_16_Scene_09|Episode #16]].
| Most of the images in the OA were recycled from [[FGC:Episode_16_Scene_09|Episode #16]].
''(On-Air Renewal follows the original OA)''
|-
|-
|}
|}
Line 691: Line 693:
| [[Image:21 C191a.jpg]]
| [[Image:21 C191a.jpg]]
[[Image:21 C191b.jpg]]
[[Image:21 C191b.jpg]]
|
| Interestingly, this cut seems more detailed in the OA version.
|-
|-
| [[FGC:Episode_21_Scene_08#cut_21_195|195]]
| [[FGC:Episode_21_Scene_08#cut_21_195|195]]
Line 757: Line 759:
[[Image:21 C242b.jpg]]
[[Image:21 C242b.jpg]]
| The DC added some video effects to Rei's face.
| The DC added some video effects to Rei's face.
''(in this sequence, On-Air Renewal follows the '''DC''')''
|-
|-
| [[FGC:Episode_21_Scene_09#cut_21_245|245]]
| [[FGC:Episode_21_Scene_09#cut_21_245|245]]
Line 892: Line 896:
| [[Image:21 C275a.jpg]]
| [[Image:21 C275a.jpg]]
[[Image:21 C275b.jpg]]
[[Image:21 C275b.jpg]]
|
| The fan rotates faster in the OA.
|-
|-
| [[FGC:Episode_21_Scene_10#cut_21_277|277]]
| [[FGC:Episode_21_Scene_10#cut_21_277|277]]
Line 914: Line 918:


[[Image:21 C279c.jpg]]
[[Image:21 C279c.jpg]]
|
|''(On-Air Renewal follows the original OA)''
|-
|-
|}
|}
[[Category:Guides]]
[[Category:Comparison Pages]]
[[Category:A to Z]]

Revision as of 10:04, 6 March 2024

As with the rest of the DC episodes, a lot of the cuts were redrawn to be as similar as possible to the original ones and are almost indistinguishable from them, while others were radically modified. The "On-Air Version" of Episode 21 present in the Renewal edition actually uses the DC version of those cuts that were redrawn with minimal changes, and simply omits the footage that wasn't present in the original OA. Exceptions to this rule will be noted below.

Scene 01: Adam

Cut OA DC Comments
305                                    
The entire Scene 01 was added in the DC. The OA episode starts with the usual opening sequence.
306A

307

308

309



Scene 02: Professor Fuyutsuki

Cut OA DC Comments
001

OA cuts fades in from black, and the credit counter goes from 049 to 048 (just like in Episode 13). In DC the counter is stuck at 999.
002B
009 In the OA edition, Misato removes her ID and handgun together from an interior jacket pocket. The result is a little awkward, as it looks like the two items are fused together. This is fixed in the DC edition, in which Misato's ID is already on the table in front of her, and she simply removes her handgun from her jacket pocket and places it on the table with her ID.
034

Yui's expression changes and she blushes slightly in the OA version when talking about her future family life. Her face remains immobile in the DC.
035 DC zooms slightly in. The cut has been reanimated (the background is in a slightly different position)

Scene 03: Rokubungi Gendo

Cut OA DC Comments
058

Redrawn for DC. Yui moves only her head in the DC when she's talking, while in the OA she moves her entire torso.
310 New sequence for DC.
311

312
313
314

315
316

317

318
319

320

321

322



Scene 04: The Antarctic Investigation

Cut OA DC Comments
072

The ship moves in the OA cut with respect to the "icebergs", while it remains stationary in the DC.
076

The reflections in the ship's windows look different between OA and DC.
324 New cuts added in the DC.
325
326 Note that the underground cavern under Antartica was added for the DC. Fuyutuski doesn't even mention it in the OA.
327

104/105 OA were fused into 327 DC, while adding with new animation.

(On-Air Renewal follows the original OA)

104
105



Scene 05: A Prototype for a God

Cut OA DC Comments
111

The foreground moves in the OA.
112

New cuts for the DC.
113

114

115

117 The OA version of this cut has a text overlay (Gendo Ikari, Director)

(the On-Air Renewal version restores the caption)

328

New sequence for the DC. Fuyutsuki's dialogue about the similarity of the Geofront to the South Pole cavern was added for the DC.
329
330

331

136

Redrawn for the DC.
137

Redrawn for the DC.
138

Redrawn for the DC. Ritsuko's jacket and hair look different.
140 Redrawn for the DC.
142 Redrawn for the DC.
143 Redrawn for the DC.
144

Redrawn for the DC.

Scene 06: A Mother

Cut OA DC Comments
Title2 The 21' designation for the DC episode was added in Renewal.
147B
147D

160

Misato opens her eyes a little earlier in the DC, and Kaji's embrace is a little different.
161
164
332 New sequence for the DC.
333
334
335
336A

337
338
336B

339
340

341
342

343

344
345



Scene 07: Contact

Cut OA DC Comments
166
174

Most of the images in the OA were recycled from Episode #16.

(On-Air Renewal follows the original OA)



Scene 08: Rei I

Cut OA DC Comments
183 Ritsuko is drawn differently, and the railway pylons' reflections were added in the DC.
186

188

191

Interestingly, this cut seems more detailed in the OA version.
195 Ritsuko's expression is slightly different, and she keeps her mouth closed in the OA.
197

The captions were added in the DC (Geofront Artificial Canopy / Lower Level 2 Support Area (Future Location))



Scene 09: Old Hag

Cut OA DC Comments
221

222

223

242

The DC added some video effects to Rei's face.

(in this sequence, On-Air Renewal follows the DC)

245

247

250 It's not only a coloration error, the whole frame is redrawn in the DC.
253

255

The DC zooms in slightly.
258

The image is a lot more detailed in the DC. The upper bridge is raised in the OA, while it's lowered in the DC.



Scene 10: Kaji's Death

Cut OA DC Comments
347 New sequence for the DC.
348
263
264

349

Kaji's talks about the Adam embryo he stole only in the DC.
267

269

271

275

The fan rotates faster in the OA.
277

279

(On-Air Renewal follows the original OA)
Retrieved from "https://wiki.evageeks.org/index.php?title=Guides:Episode_21_OA_vs._DC&oldid=115946"