Guides:Episode 22 OA vs. DC: Difference between revisions

From EvaWiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
No edit summary
(Tweakage)
Line 1: Line 1:
Most cuts are simple retakes, with some being more extensive than others (i.e., completely redone from scratch, vs. simply having the cel element redone). See also the comments.
NOTE: In the Renewal version of OA 22, very little of the actual OA footage remains intact; in most cases, it is replaced with the revised DC equivalents. In such cases, screenshots were acquired from an earlier DVD release (hence the discrepancy in image quality).
NOTE: In the Renewal version of OA 22, very little of the actual OA footage remains intact; in most cases, it is replaced with the revised DC equivalents. In such cases, screenshots were acquired from an earlier DVD release (hence the discrepancy in image quality).
Most cuts are simple retakes, with some being more extensive than others (i.e., completely redone from scratch, vs. simply having the cel element redone). See also the comments.


==Scene 4: Bad Day at Work==
==Scene 4: Bad Day at Work==
Line 35: Line 35:
| [[Image:22 C067 oa 1.jpg|150px]] <br/><br/> [[Image:22 C067 oa 2.jpg|150px]]
| [[Image:22 C067 oa 1.jpg|150px]] <br/><br/> [[Image:22 C067 oa 2.jpg|150px]]
| [[Image:22 C067 dc 1.jpg|150px]] <br/><br/> [[Image:22 C067 dc 2.jpg|150px]]
| [[Image:22 C067 dc 1.jpg|150px]] <br/><br/> [[Image:22 C067 dc 2.jpg|150px]]
| DC Ritsuko's expression immediately differs from C065. She is visibly sullied, which isn't evident in the original.
| DC Ritsuko is visibly sullied, which isn't evident in the original. Her expression also immediately differs from C065.  
|-
|-
| C068
| C068
Line 55: Line 55:
| [[Image:22 C073 oa.jpg|150px]]
| [[Image:22 C073 oa.jpg|150px]]
| [[Image:22_C073_dc.jpg|150px]]
| [[Image:22_C073_dc.jpg|150px]]
| DC Asuka's expression is considerably more "weary".
| DC Asuka's expression is "weary" from the start, rather than simply surly.
|-
|-
| C075
| C075
Line 75: Line 75:
| [[Image:22 C081 oa 1.jpg|150px]] <br/><br/> [[Image:22 C081 oa 2.jpg|150px]]
| [[Image:22 C081 oa 1.jpg|150px]] <br/><br/> [[Image:22 C081 oa 2.jpg|150px]]
| [[Image:22 C081 dc 1.jpg|150px]] <br/><br/> [[Image:22 C081 dc 2.jpg|150px]]
| [[Image:22 C081 dc 1.jpg|150px]] <br/><br/> [[Image:22 C081 dc 2.jpg|150px]]
| DC Asuka straightens her neck out, but she doesn't tilt her head.
| DC Asuka straightens her neck out rather than tilts her head.
|-
|-
| C083
| C083
Line 90: Line 90:
| [[Image:22 C085 oa 1.jpg|150px]] <br/><br/> [[Image:22 C085 oa 2.jpg|150px]]  
| [[Image:22 C085 oa 1.jpg|150px]] <br/><br/> [[Image:22 C085 oa 2.jpg|150px]]  
| [[Image:22 C085 dc 01.jpg|150px]] <br/><br/> [[Image:22 C085 dc 02.jpg|150px]]  
| [[Image:22 C085 dc 01.jpg|150px]] <br/><br/> [[Image:22 C085 dc 02.jpg|150px]]  
| The two versions begin with Asuka's gesticulations "matching up", but DC soon diverges...
| ''The two versions begin with Asuka's gesticulations "matching up", but DC soon diverges. Asuka's dialogue is provided as the common element.''
 
Asuka's dialogue is provided as the common element.  


Asuka: "What?!"
Asuka: "What?!"
Line 120: Line 118:
| [[Image:22 C090 oa 1.jpg|150px]] <br/><br/> [[Image:22 C090 oa 2.jpg|150px]]
| [[Image:22 C090 oa 1.jpg|150px]] <br/><br/> [[Image:22 C090 oa 2.jpg|150px]]
| [[Image:22 C090 dc 1.jpg|150px]] <br/><br/> [[Image:22 C090 dc 2.jpg|150px]] <br/><br/> [[Image:22 C090 dc 3.jpg|150px]]
| [[Image:22 C090 dc 1.jpg|150px]] <br/><br/> [[Image:22 C090 dc 2.jpg|150px]] <br/><br/> [[Image:22 C090 dc 3.jpg|150px]]
| <br/>
| '''OA:''' Asuka's face is in a different position from the end of C088. She simply brings it down when she speaks. <br/> '''DC:''' Asuka's head starts in the same position as C088. She aggressively jerks her face to the side (with her hair subsequently settling into place).
|-
|-
| C092
| C092
Line 155: Line 153:
| [[Image:22_C164_oa_1.jpg|150px]] <br/><br/> [[Image:22_C164_oa_2.jpg|150px]] <br/><br/> [[Image:22_C164_oa_3.jpg|150px]]  
| [[Image:22_C164_oa_1.jpg|150px]] <br/><br/> [[Image:22_C164_oa_2.jpg|150px]] <br/><br/> [[Image:22_C164_oa_3.jpg|150px]]  
| [[Image:22_C164_dc_1.jpg|150px]] <br/><br/> [[Image:22_C164_dc_2.jpg|150px]] <br/><br/> [[Image:22_C164_dc_3.jpg|150px]]  
| [[Image:22_C164_dc_1.jpg|150px]] <br/><br/> [[Image:22_C164_dc_2.jpg|150px]] <br/><br/> [[Image:22_C164_dc_3.jpg|150px]]  
| The fire from the positron rifle now has a much higher arch. Arael's silhouette redone (with three little "stars" removed, in addition) and placed further from the camera. Some left-to-right panning added.
| The fire from the positron rifle now has a much higher arch. Arael's silhouette redone (with the three little "stars" removed, in addition) and placed further from the camera. Some left-to-right panning added.
|-
|-
| C166
| C166
Line 170: Line 168:
| valign="bottom" | [[Image:22_C208_oa.jpg|150px]]
| valign="bottom" | [[Image:22_C208_oa.jpg|150px]]
| [[Image:22_C208_dc_1.jpg|150px]] <br/><br/> [[Image:22_C208_dc_2.jpg|150px]]
| [[Image:22_C208_dc_1.jpg|150px]] <br/><br/> [[Image:22_C208_dc_2.jpg|150px]]
| New animation created (versus recyclage).
| New animation created (versus the OA's recyclage).
|}
|}


Line 208: Line 206:
|-
|-
| C259B
| C259B
| <br/>
| colspan="2" align="center" | [[Image:22_C259B_dc_1.jpg|150px]] <br/><br/> [[Image:22_C259B_dc_3.jpg|150px]] <br/><br/> [[Image:22_C259B_dc_5.jpg|150px]]  
| [[Image:22_C259B_dc_1.jpg|150px]] <br/><br/> [[Image:22_C259B_dc_3.jpg|150px]] <br/><br/> [[Image:22_C259B_dc_5.jpg|150px]]  
| New cut.
| New cut.
|-
|-
Line 221: Line 218:
|-
|-
| C259D
| C259D
| <br/>
| colspan="2" align="center" | [[Image:22 C259D zero.jpg|150px]]
| [[Image:22 C259D zero.jpg|150px]]
| New cut.
| New cut.
|-
|-
Line 228: Line 224:
| [[Image:22_C261A_oa_1.jpg|150px]] <br/><br/> [[Image:22_C261A_oa_2.jpg|150px]]
| [[Image:22_C261A_oa_1.jpg|150px]] <br/><br/> [[Image:22_C261A_oa_2.jpg|150px]]
| [[Image:22_C261A_dc_1.jpg|150px]] <br/><br/> [[Image:22_C261A_dc_2.jpg|150px]]
| [[Image:22_C261A_dc_1.jpg|150px]] <br/><br/> [[Image:22_C261A_dc_2.jpg|150px]]
| Redone from scratch. Fuyutsuki moves his entire head in the OA; in the DC, he only shifts his eyes.
| OA Fuyutsuki moves his entire head; in the DC, he only shifts his eyes.
|-
|-
| C266
| C266
Line 238: Line 234:
| valign="bottom" | [[Image:22_C267_oa_1.jpg|150px]] <br/><br/> [[Image:22_C267_oa_2.jpg|150px]] <br/><br/> [[Image:22_C267_oa_3.jpg|150px]]  
| valign="bottom" | [[Image:22_C267_oa_1.jpg|150px]] <br/><br/> [[Image:22_C267_oa_2.jpg|150px]] <br/><br/> [[Image:22_C267_oa_3.jpg|150px]]  
| [[Image:22_C267_dc_1.jpg|150px]] <br/><br/> [[Image:22_C267_dc_2.jpg|150px]] <br/><br/> [[Image:22_C267_dc_3.jpg|150px]] <br/><br/> [[Image:22_C267_dc_4.jpg|150px]]
| [[Image:22_C267_dc_1.jpg|150px]] <br/><br/> [[Image:22_C267_dc_2.jpg|150px]] <br/><br/> [[Image:22_C267_dc_3.jpg|150px]] <br/><br/> [[Image:22_C267_dc_4.jpg|150px]]
| The animation is redrawn and "extended".
| The animation is redrawn and "extended": The foot's placement is initially different, but it subsequently "follows the path" of the original.  
|-
|-
| C268
| C268

Revision as of 04:12, 22 January 2008

Most cuts are simple retakes, with some being more extensive than others (i.e., completely redone from scratch, vs. simply having the cel element redone). See also the comments.

NOTE: In the Renewal version of OA 22, very little of the actual OA footage remains intact; in most cases, it is replaced with the revised DC equivalents. In such cases, screenshots were acquired from an earlier DVD release (hence the discrepancy in image quality).

Scene 4: Bad Day at Work


Cut OA DC Comments
C063
C064
C065
C066




C067



DC Ritsuko is visibly sullied, which isn't evident in the original. Her expression also immediately differs from C065.
C068
C069











Asuka's reflection removed.
C070
C073 DC Asuka's expression is "weary" from the start, rather than simply surly.
C075











DC opts to cut away with Asuka not quite so close to the camera.
C078

OA: Asuka blinks at a point (not shown here).
DC: Asuka "sniffles" instead.
C079








C081



DC Asuka straightens her neck out rather than tilts her head.
C083







DC Asuka "pushes" her face to the side when she speaks, instead of lifting her face before bringing it down.
C084 The Asuka element is redone.
C085



The two versions begin with Asuka's gesticulations "matching up", but DC soon diverges. Asuka's dialogue is provided as the common element.

Asuka: "What?!"

"Are you so happy that I can't pilot my Eva?!"
"There's nothing to worry about! If another Angel attacks us,


"the great, invincible Shinji-sama will take care of it for us!"












"We don't have to do anything!"
C088
C090





OA: Asuka's face is in a different position from the end of C088. She simply brings it down when she speaks.
DC: Asuka's head starts in the same position as C088. She aggressively jerks her face to the side (with her hair subsequently settling into place).
C092





Scene 6: Arael's Attack ~Hallelujah~


Cut OA DC Comments
C154 Bridge crew brought out of silhouette and given "surprised" poses. Light attack intensified. Different font used for display screen. Image cropped more tightly.
C156 Display completely redone.
C160








C164







The fire from the positron rifle now has a much higher arch. Arael's silhouette redone (with the three little "stars" removed, in addition) and placed further from the camera. Some left-to-right panning added.
C166
C207
C208

New animation created (versus the OA's recyclage).


Scene 9: Amen ~ Arael's Defeat


Cut OA DC Comments
C224 Eva-02 redrawn. Lighting effects altered.
C230
C239
C241








C255

Fuyutsuki originally shifts his head before speaking; it remains stationary in the retake.
C259B



New cut.
C259C    

   

   

   

New cut.
C259D New cut.
C261A



OA Fuyutsuki moves his entire head; in the DC, he only shifts his eyes.
C266







Eva-00 is redone, now animated pulling the Spear back as she aims.
C267









The animation is redrawn and "extended": The foot's placement is initially different, but it subsequently "follows the path" of the original.
C268




C272



Audio change: The Spear (?) now makes a "roaring" sound.
C274 in the OA is replaced with C274A ~ C274C.
C274A    

   

   

New cut.
C274B    

   

   

New cut.
C274 (OA)/
C274C (DC)













C274C follows the original C274 closely, while adding a more distinct "membranous" element to the ATF. A new frame of animation is also added onto the very end.
C276















Different background painting. The purplish sphere expands to a much larger size and lasts a longer duration before fading out. The twinkle of light is now still visible at the end of the cut, whereas it faded out before. The "Wings of Light" sound effect from Episode 12 has been removed.
C278




C280

Fuyutsuki now remains stationary, rather than raising his body again before speaking.
C282B







OA: The Spear simply drifts from left to right across the screen. Earth is visible below.
DC: The Spear revolves in space, occasionally catching some light. Appears to be a simple utilization of CGI.
Retrieved from "https://wiki.evageeks.org/index.php?title=Guides:Episode_22_OA_vs._DC&oldid=14024"